Zelda Mafia Round 2 Night One (IMPORTANT, REPLACEMENT NEEDED!)

The Missing Link · #261

DOUBLE POST: Conversely, if I had omitted the second question in the post you referenced, it would have meant that I knew the win condition for the Mafia, therefore making me a target of the town.

My strategy this game is to imagine the strategy of every role and consider what they'd do. And then be very public about the strategy. The Townies have to consider the strategy of the Mafia, and the Mafia has to consider the strategy of the Townies. And both have to consider the Slasher. I merely laid out the cards on the table. Truth be told, everyone is going to know the answer to one of the two questions... except the Slasher, who knows both.

I am nobody · #262

DOUBLE POST: I finaly got my internet back, so I can contribute more now.

Mikhail Gorbachev · #263

The Missing Link wrote: If I'm a Townie, the last thing I want to do is to confess I'm a Townie. If I claimed I knew exactly what the win condition for the Townies was, based upon the role PM... it would therefore mean that I'd have been the Mafia's first target, would it not?

Don't pretend you don't know how the game is played. Mafia members know who other mafia members are. Being a townie just tells the mafia you're not a hero or a slasher. That would make someone less of a target. The mafia's first target would be whoever they think is a hero.

DOUBLE POST: This is how you do a proper double post, kulaks.

Daos · #264

He wasn't.

ZeldaGirl · #265

Again:

FoS: TML

TML, like Fnord said, the mafia KNOW WHO EACH OTHER ARE. They want to get rid of EVERYONE ELSE. So, if you WERE NOT MAFIA, they would know. You WANT people to know that you are a townie, because that means that they won't lynch you!

The Missing Link · #266

Well, Mikhail, my best defense is forgetfulness. I was at work.

Oh, and this:

--------- DELETED PER CRAVADAA

Daos · #267

Your wrong though TML, the one thing the townies would not want to do it say they are a hero.

ZeldaGirl · #268

DOUBLE POST:

I retract my FoS on ian. He's just proven to me he's innocent.

^^How do we know that's not photoshop'd?

I am nobody · #269

TML: You are suspicious right now. It clearly says how I win (As a townie) in my PM. You said you don't know how the town wins. So, unless my PM was for some reason unique, you can't be a town member. So you are either a hero, mafia, or the slasher. Unless Crav changed the hero's objectives, that also says that you win when all evil has been destroyed. So, that leaves the mafia and slasher. Any explanation?

FoS: TML.

Daos · #270

We don't, anyone with even a small amount of knowledge with photoshop could do something like that.

I am nobody · #271

IGNORE THIS POST. TOO MANY PEOPLE POSTED WHILE I WAS TYPING.

ZeldaGirl · #272

But, then again, how do we know that Daos and Mikhail are trying to string us along?

I am nobody · #273

FoS: Everyone. They are trying to stop me from double posting.

Daos · #274

I'm just trying to figure out who is being suspicious.

ZeldaGirl · #275

I'm torn.

I'm suspicious of TML because of the reason I originally gave. But, his PM... the last line is what is said when a person is a townie (I know, I have the same line). HOWEVER - ian used those exact words in his post! So, the question is, does TML honestly have a townie role, or did he copy ian's wording and hope it would fly?

I am nobody · #276

^ The same wording was used for townie and heros roles last game.

Blake · #277

My question about that PM is.

My topic reads "Zelda mafia 2 role" not "Zelda mafia2 role"

So I'm curious if Crav (I guess) 'rushed' so to speak or didn't have any consistency on the topic of his PMs(which is very real I'll admit).

Is anyone else willing to try and confirm this? If many of our PM Titles read the way mine does then perhaps there is something suspicious that can automatically single it out as a photoshop.

Again, it can very certainly be nothing big. Just a thought I had.

The Missing Link · #278

Well, it's obviously Photoshopped, ZG. Look at the blurry text. :P How am I supposed to say it's not?

As for whether or not the sentence in question is manipulated or not, well, I'll tell you it's not, but that's not going to hold up in court, obviously. And of course, since ian was kind enough to blab the code phrase--or at least a variation of it--I don't get any points for getting the phrase right. All I've really got going for me is the speed in which I was able to hide the relevant information; Cravdaa is actively posting, so his post count is different. If I had taken extra time to make this image, it wouldn't be one post off his current post count.

i_am_nobody wrote:^ The same wording was used for townie and heros roles last game.

Which I didn't have access to, thank you.

Daos · #279

Ian and TML are both being the most suspicious right now but I wonder if ZG isn't just trying to cast any suspicion off herself.

Double Post: By the way, my PM subject reads exactly like TML's (Mafia2).

Cravdraa · #280

Ugh.

7. Don't quote my PMs. You can paraphrase, but that's it.

If you aren't allowed to quote them, What in god's name made you think it was okay to take a picture of it and edit it?

I'm a NEUTRAL host, here people. I can't be somebody's alibi.

TML delete that now.